Private vs Public Adoption: What Are The Differences?

Adoption can be a life-changing experience for parents and children alike. It is important to consider all of the options available during this process, such as private vs public adoption, which come with their own distinct advantages and disadvantages. In this blog post, we will explore how these two types of adoptions differ so that you can make an informed decision about which route is right for your family. From considering the roles of different entities in both processes to discussing which provisions are offered within each option, by the end of this article you will come away with a better understanding on exactly what’s involved in private and public adoption.

Overview of Private vs Public Adoption

Adoption is an amazing way to start or grow a family, but making the decision on which route to take can be tough. Private vs public adoption are two common avenues for hopeful parents to explore. Private adoption involves working with an adoption agency that facilitates the process between adoptive parents and birth parents. It can be more costly and take longer than public adoption, but it often gives adoptive parents more options in choosing a child and having a relationship with birth parents. Public adoption, on the other hand, involves adopting through the foster care system. It can be less expensive and faster than private adoption, but it often involves adopting older children who have experienced trauma and may have specific emotional needs. Ultimately, the decision on which type of adoption to pursue is deeply personal and requires careful consideration.

What Is The Difference Between Private Adoption And Foster Care Adoption?

The core difference between private adoption and foster care adoption lies in the process, cost, and the children available for adoption.

Image Credit:

In private adoption, prospective adoptive parents work directly with a private agency or sometimes an attorney to adopt a child, often a newborn, from expectant parents who have voluntarily placed their child for adoption. This process can be more expensive, with costs ranging anywhere from $20,000 to $50,000, largely due to the legal, medical, and professional services required. Additionally, private adoption usually involves a degree of openness between the birth parents and adoptive parents, which can include ongoing communication or visits.

Foster care adoption, on the other hand, involves adopting a child who has been placed in the public child welfare system due to abuse, neglect, or other family issues that prevent them from safely living with their birth families. The process is usually facilitated by a public agency, and the costs are significantly lower, often under $3,000, with many states providing subsidies to adoptive parents. The children available through foster care adoption are typically older and may have special needs. While reunification with their birth family is always the first goal in foster care, if it’s deemed not in the child’s best interest, then the child becomes legally free for adoption.

Pros and Cons of Private Adoption

Private adoption is one of the options for those who wish to adopt a child. It is a process where individuals or couples work with an adoption agency or an attorney to find and adopt a child. Compared to public adoption, private adoption comes with its own set of pros and cons. One of the advantages of private adoption is that it can be faster compared to public adoption.

Private adoption also allows adoptive parents to have more control over the process and select the birth mother and child they want to adopt. However, one of the drawbacks is that private adoption can be more expensive as it requires adoptive parents to pay for various fees. Additionally, adoptive parents must ensure that they are working with a reputable agency or attorney to avoid any fraud or unethical practices. Despite its pros and cons, private adoption remains a popular option for families who want to expand their family and provide a child with a loving home.

Pros and Cons of Public Adoption

When considering adoption, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of public adoption. One major benefit of public adoption is the potential to provide a loving home and family to a child who may have been otherwise neglected or mistreated. Additionally, the cost of public adoption can be significantly lower than private adoption.

However, it’s important to recognize that public adoption can also come with its challenges. Potential delays and uncertainty in the adoption process can be frustrating, and children who have experienced trauma may require extra patience and support. Ultimately, it’s important to carefully consider both the benefits and drawbacks of public adoption before making a decision.

Financial Implications of Both Types of Adoption

When it comes to adoption, the financial implications vary depending on the type of adoption a family chooses. Domestic adoption typically costs less than international adoption, but both options require financial preparation. Domestic adoptions often involve expenses such as home studies, legal fees, and birth mother expenses. On the other hand, international adoption can come with fees for travel, visas, and translation services. Regardless of the type of adoption, it’s essential to budget accordingly and consider any available financial assistance options. While the costs of adoption may seem daunting, the reward of welcoming a child into your family is priceless.

Matching Processes for Private vs Public Adoption

When it comes to adoption, there are two main avenues to explore: private and public. Both options involve a matching process that is designed to find the perfect fit between a child and their new forever family. However, there are some key differences between private and public adoption. Private adoption typically involves working with an adoption agency or attorney to find a birth mother who is looking for adoptive parents.

Public adoption, on the other hand, involves working with the state or county to find a child who is in need of a permanent home. Regardless of which option you choose, the matching process is an essential part of the adoption journey. It’s important to work with professionals who understand your needs and can help you navigate the process with care and compassion. With the right support, you can find the child who completes your family and brings joy to your life for years to come.

Legal Implications of Both Types of Adoption

Adoption is a life-changing decision that has legal implications. There are two types of adoption: domestic adoption and international adoption. Both legal procedures have their own set of rules and regulations. Domestic adoption requires a court order to finalize the adoption, while international adoption requires clearance from both the US government and the foreign country where the child is from.

Understanding the legal implications of adoption is important to ensure a smooth process and protect both the adoptive parents and the child. It is highly recommended to consult with a legal expert and navigate through the legal proceedings with caution. Adoption is a beautiful way to expand your family, and with the right legal guidance, it can be a fulfilling journey.

In the end, private and public adoptions both have their merits and drawbacks. It is important to consider all factors in order to determine what option is best for you.

If you opt for a private adoption route, make sure to properly plan out finances in order to make your dream of expanding your family come true. For either option, it is important to be aware of the legal implications that may arise, so be sure to work with an attorney experienced in adoption law.

Ultimately, whichever route you decide upon, it’s a unique and exciting journey that will bring immense joy into anyone’s life—and what greater blessing than uniting a child with a loving home? Adoption should always be celebrated as we are reminded of the beauty in making a dream become reality.

Below, we will share further details on areas where private vs. public adoption differs.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): Wait Times

When exploring adoption avenues, wait times are an important factor to consider. The time it takes to adopt a child can greatly vary between private adoption and foster care adoption.

In private adoption, the wait times can be relatively shorter. The process involves finding a match with a birth mother, which can sometimes occur quite quickly, especially with the aid of a reputable adoption agency or attorney. However, the timing largely depends on the adoptive parents’ preferences, such as the age or health of the child, which can extend the wait times.

On the contrary, foster care adoption tends to have longer wait times. Children in foster care may first go through attempts of reunification with their biological family. Only when these efforts have been exhausted will the children become legally free for adoption. This process can take months or even years to complete. However, if adoptive parents are open to adopting older children, sibling groups, or children with special needs, the wait time may be significantly shorter.

In conclusion, while private adoption often has shorter wait times, both routes require patience and resilience. It’s also crucial to remember that each adoption journey is unique, and wait times can vary greatly depending on various factors.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): Uncertainties

Private adoption and foster care adoption are two viable paths for expanding a family, though both come with their own set of uncertainties.

In private adoption, the primary uncertainty lies in the matching process. Prospective adoptive parents are often paired with a birth mother through an agency or attorney. However, the birth mother retains the right to change her mind about the adoption up until the point when her parental rights are legally terminated. This can result in an emotional roller coaster for hopeful adoptive parents, who may face disappointment if the birth mother decides to keep the child.

Foster care adoption, on the other hand, carries a different set of uncertainties. The primary goal of the foster care system is to reunite children with their biological families, if possible. As such, a child placed with a foster family may eventually return to their biological family, which can be a heart-wrenching experience for foster parents. Even when a child becomes legally free for adoption, there might be relatives who step forward to adopt the child, which can further prolong the process or even derail the adoption plans.

In conclusion, while both private and foster care adoption can lead to the joyous outcome of a larger family, they also both carry uncertainties that prospective parents must be prepared to navigate. The journey to adoption is often a test of resilience, patience, and emotional strength, and it’s essential to have a strong support network and to understand the possible challenges that may arise.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): The Possibility of Disruption

Private infant adoption comes with its own unique set of challenges, one of which is the potential for disruption. Disruption in adoption refers to an adoption process that has been initiated but does not ultimately result in the placement of a child with the prospective adoptive parents. In the context of private infant adoption, the disruption typically occurs if the birth mother, who has the legal right to change her decision until her parental rights are terminated, chooses to keep the child.

The degree of uncertainty can be high, especially considering the emotional attachment that prospective parents develop even during the pregnancy phase. The possibility of disruption can cause considerable emotional distress for the adoptive parents. However, it’s important to remember that in the realm of adoption, the birth mother’s rights must be respected and her decision accepted gracefully.

Adoption agencies usually provide extensive counseling and support to birth mothers to help them make informed decisions. Still, there’s always a chance that the birth mother could change her mind after the child is born. The period between the child’s birth and the termination of parental rights is often the most uncertain and emotionally challenging part of the adoption journey.

To prepare for this possibility, it’s crucial for prospective adoptive parents to have a strong support network and professional guidance. They should be made aware of this potential risk at the beginning of the process to manage their expectations and emotional investment. In the end, while disruption can be a painful part of the journey, it also serves as a testament to the complexity and depth of emotions involved in the process of adoption.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): The Possibility of Reunification

In foster care adoption, the ever-present possibility of reunification with the biological family exists. The primary aim of the foster care system is to provide temporary care while working towards this reunification if it is in the child’s best interest. This process often involves steps such as parental counseling, substance abuse treatment, or other efforts to create a safe and stable family environment. Until parental rights are terminated, the biological parents maintain the right to regain custody. For prospective adoptive parents, this means they may face an emotional journey, as a child they hope to adopt may ultimately return to their biological family. It is an aspect of foster care adoption that requires immense emotional resilience, patience, and understanding of the child’s best interest.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): Adoptee’s Age

When considering adoption, the child’s age is a significant factor to discuss. In private adoption, infants are most commonly placed for adoption. This often allows adoptive parents to experience many of the child’s “firsts” — from their first smile to their first steps. It also allows the adoptive parents to shape the child’s early development. However, adopting an infant also means waking up for late-night feedings and changing diapers, which are responsibilities not everyone is prepared to take on.

Image Credit:

On the other hand, foster care adoption usually involves older children, often ranging from toddlers to teenagers. According to data from the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, the average age of children in foster care is 7.7 years old. Adopting an older child can come with its own unique challenges, such as dealing with trauma or behavioral issues. However, it can also be incredibly rewarding. Older children are often overlooked in the adoption process, and adoptive parents can significantly and positively impact their lives.

In both private and foster care adoption, it’s crucial to consider not just the age of the child you wish to adopt but also the emotional, financial, and physical responsibilities that come with that age. This understanding can help prospective adoptive parents make the best decision for their family.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Foster Care): The Role of Biological Parents

The extent of biological parents’ involvement in a child’s life can vary significantly between private and foster care adoption. In private adoption, particularly in cases of closed adoption, the biological parents typically have little to no contact with the child after the adoption process is finalized. For instance, in the case of John and Lisa, who adopted a newborn through a private agency, the biological mother chose a closed adoption. This means John and Lisa have no ongoing relationship with the biological mother, and their daughter will not have contact with her unless she chooses to seek this out when she is older.

On the other hand, in foster care adoption, there can be more opportunities for ongoing contact with the biological family, depending on the circumstances. In some cases, there may be visitation rights or other forms of contact agreed upon during the adoption process. For example, Sarah and Peter adopted a six-year-old boy, Mark, from foster care. Mark’s biological mother had struggled with substance abuse but had since undergone treatment. As part of the adoption arrangement, she was granted supervised visitations. This way, Mark maintains a connection to his biological roots, and his adoptive parents, Sarah and Peter, support this relationship.

However, it’s important to remember that each adoption scenario is unique, and the biological parent’s involvement level can vary widely depending on the specific circumstances. Prospective adoptive parents should seek guidance from adoption professionals to understand what to expect in their situation.

Private Adoption vs Public Adoption (Conclusion)

In the world of adoption, cost is another significant factor that differentiates private adoption from foster care adoption. Private adoption often involves substantial financial commitment. The cost can range from $20,000 to $45,000 or more, depending on various factors such as agency fees, legal expenses, medical expenses related to the birth, and travel costs among others. It’s important to note that some agencies offer a sliding scale fee structure based on the adoptive family’s income.

On the contrary, foster care adoption tends to be significantly less expensive, if not free. The state often covers most, if not all, of the costs associated with the adoption process, from home study to legal fees. Additionally, families who adopt from foster care may be eligible for federal or state subsidies to help cover the costs of raising a child, and the child may also qualify for Medicaid and college tuition assistance in some states.

However, it is important to remember that the cost of raising a child extends beyond the initial adoption process, and prospective adoptive parents should consider their long-term financial readiness. Regardless of the method of adoption chosen, the commitment to provide for a child in all aspects, including finances, is a profound one that should be undertaken with careful consideration.

Adopting From Foster Care

Adopting from foster care entails a process similar to other types of adoption. It involves making decisions, completing paperwork, and preparing to fulfill the dream of building a family. However, there are several notable differences in foster care adoptions:

  • Age Range: While it is possible to adopt a baby from foster care, the majority of children available for adoption are typically aged from toddlers to 21, with an average age of eight years old.
  • Trauma and Rehabilitation: Since all children in foster care have experienced some form of trauma, parents intending to adopt from foster care undergo specific training. This training helps them comprehend the effects of trauma and equips them to assist in a child’s healing process.
  • Agency Collaboration: Parents who choose to adopt from foster care often collaborate with either a public agency or a private agency that has a contractual agreement with the state to provide adoption services.
  • Financial Considerations: One significant advantage of adopting from foster care is the minimal to no associated cost.

By following these guidelines and understanding the unique dynamics of foster care adoption, prospective parents can navigate the process professionally while making a positive impact on the lives of children in need. Contact the Therapeutic Family Life Team if you have any questions and we will do our best to answer your questions!

Leon Smith
+ posts

Leon Joseph Smith is the founder and CEO of Therapeutic Family Life, a child-placing and adoption agency with 30 years of experience. With licenses and certificates including LPC, LMFT, LCDC, BCIA, CCDS, and SOTP, Leon brings a wealth of expertise to his role. He has a strong background in counseling, having served children and adolescents with severe emotional and mental disabilities. Leon's focus has always been on providing a "win-win" situation for everyone involved, ensuring the emotional stability of foster children, the expertise of caregivers, and compliance with state regulations. His compassionate approach has been the cornerstone of Therapeutic Family Life's success.